14 Jun 2019, 14:44
Too much expertise, power etc in one place. Removes competition, which is part of the fundamental success story that is capitalism.
We are already down to 2 (big) defense contractors for fighters. If the consolidation keeps up, it's going to bite us in the end. Let's say you put specs out for PCA. Lockheed Martin comes in with a proposal, and Boeing does too. They both meet specs but are radically different in appearance and how they achieve those specs. The loser isn't always. Look at what the YF-17A morphed into for the Navy.
Once you have just one group of engineers arriving at one solution, you've lost something that's priceless - competition. Look at what Northrup/McDonnell Douglas came up with for the ATF. I'm not going to argue which plane was superior, but the YF-23A could have paved the way for even more advanced technologies. Hopefully, it exists and is flying in some form or fashion today, as was previously alluded to.
Without competition, it would have never been built..